Forex Trading Library

Le Pen & Frexit: Taking back monetary sovereignty

2 299

While names such as Emmanuel Macron, or Francois Fillon might not be that popular especially for an international reader, the name Marine Le Pen no doubt does. In a wave of protectionist and populist policies that has gripped most of the Western world, Le Pen is another of the famous names that echoes with the U.S. President Donald Trump, UK’s Prime Minster Theresa May.

For the most part, the media has only focused on the immigration policies of Le Pen’s National Front party. While her immigration views and accusations of leaning to the far-right are splashed all over the news, for the average French citizen who goes to polls in April and could potentially decide the fate of France and that of the European Union, there are a lot more things worth considering beyond looking at just Le Pen’s immigration policies.

Le Pen’s Political Manifesto

It doesn’t make sense without looking at the entire manifesto from Le Pen’s campaign; probably something the French voter is faced with, being at the center of this event. Here are some of the most important points from Ms. Le Penn’s 144 point manifesto which can be accessed from here (in French).

1. Re-negotiate the EU deal or face Frexit

Le Pen proposed talks with the EU leadership upon coming to power to renegotiate the nation’s membership. Among the ideas floated included no more euro, cutting access to free border travel and EU budget rules.

This is somewhat similar to what David Cameron had proposed prior to Brexit, Le Pen also promises to hold a referendum on EU membership at the end of the 6-month negotiating period and that she would recommend leaving the EU if the terms are not favorable. Some experts argue even now that Brexit could have been averted if EU leaders took a more concessionary stand with the UK. But on the other hand, doing so would only mean empowering other EU member nations to come seeking favorable terms.

It is unlikely that the EU leadership will give any concessions to France either, making Frexit a possibility under Le Pen.

2. Taking back monetary sovereignty

Le Pen also proposed that leaving the euro currency would mean having to re-denominate its debt stock in the new currency and that the France’s Central Bank will defend the new currency including buying bonds from the government.

The idea of switching currencies has been widely debated but hasn’t been witnessed yet. Greece was the closest that came to being forced out from using the single currency. Logistically it would be a herculean task to implement a switch back to the French franc. Even if there is a Frexit, France will require some grace period to continue using the euro currency.

This is likely to be a key negotiating piece which the EU leaders will most like use to their advantage, making it very difficult for France to even think about abandoning the single currency. Le Pen’s proposal of mandating the central bank to buy government bonds is also not something new and is akin to the ECB currently purchasing the sovereign bonds. However, in the context of the French national bank buying French bonds, the risks of hyperinflation cannot be ruled out which can be disastrous especially without having the euro to fall back upon.

3. Protectionist policies

Le Pen proposed various measures to boost French industry, including keeping public procurement open to only French firms, ensuring that retailers keep a certain portion of French goods on their inventory, implementing restrictions to imported goods and rejection of international trade treaties.

This is again very likely going to depend on whether the French will keep the euro or switch to the franc but makes more sense under a French franc, which brings us back to the question on how trade is possible against a looming uncertainty on what currency to use.

4. Taxes and Welfare

Le Pen promises to implement a 10% tax cut on the lowest revenue bands and also cut payroll and corporate tax for SME’s. Le Pen also promises to roll back the retirement age from the current age of 62 to 60 and increase aids and benefits to the poorest among the elderly. Cutting energy prices by 5% and rolling out child benefits to one and all including some tax benefits for parents and making overtime pay tax-free.

Same as above

5. Preference for French citizens

Under this scheme, French citizens will be entitled to free education and employers who hire foreign workers will have to pay 10% of the salary in taxes.

The proposal here is akin to a social welfare state. There are also unanswered questions of where the funding for the schemes will come from and of course, this brings us back to the question on the currency.

6. Security and Defense

Campaign promises include hiring 15,000 police personnel and building jails to house 40,000 inmates and to reform laws to make it easy to expel foreigners who are convicted. More importantly, Le Pen proposed leaving the NATO’s integrated command and to boost national defense spending.

Pulling up the drawbridges would mean not just increase in hiring the police but also strengthening the border police force as well and could mean having to dip into a large or perhaps a bottomless treasure chest, something which under the given circumstances is difficult to fathom.

7. Immigration

Le Pen also promised that undocumented migrants can legalize their stay in France but that her government would curb asylum requests made abroad in French consulates. She also promised to tighten citizenship laws and repeal the current law here being born in France would give a right to citizenship. However, the most widely covered aspects of Le Pen’s immigration proposals are, of course, limiting net immigration to 10,000 people a year and stopping free healthcare and benefits to illegal migrants.

With immigration being such a hot topic at the moment, it is quite possible the French government will quickly end up in legal tussles on human rights issues, which will likely result in a Le Pen government coming under pressure in the international community.

Read more about French elections:

Leave A Reply

Your email address will not be published.